There was once
a flock of Sheep that came under the care of a Sheepdog.
"You have
to give me all your wool," said the Sheepdog.
"Why should
we do that?" asked the Sheep.
"Because I
take care of you," said the Sheepdog. "You give me your wool, and
I protect you. As your representative, I will use the wool for the
common good. It's called a 'social contract.' Don't worry.
It's a painless transaction. I'll just start from the back and pull
the wool right over your eyes. You won't notice a thing."
The Sheep
thought about the social contract thing, and it made a certain amount of
sense, so they gave the Sheepdog their wool. Before long, they noticed
that the Sheepdog was palling around with some very obese Cats.
"What's with
those Cats?" asked the Sheep.
"Oh, nothing
much," said the Sheepdog. "Those are the Fat Cats. They bring
a lot of business into the area, so it's a good idea to be friendly with
them."
"Oh, ok,"
said the Sheep. "Just curious."
Before long,
the cold weather started settling in, and the Sheep started getting cold.
"Sheepdog,"
they said. "We're cold."
"How is that
my problem?" asked the Sheepdog.
"Well, we
thought you were supposed to take care of us," replied the Sheep.
"I keep the
Wolves away," said the Sheepdog. "Cold isn't my problem."
"How about
giving us back some of that wool we gave you?" suggested the Sheep.
"You know, common good and social contract and all that?"
"Oh, no,"
said the Sheepdog. "It doesn't work that way. You give me the
wool, and I give it to the Fat Cats. They invest in our area, the
area prospers, you get wealthy enough to buy sweaters, and everything works
out for the best. But you don't have any right to warmth."
"So, what
are we supposed to do?" bleated the Sheep.
"Go to work
for the Fat Cats," said the Sheepdog. "They might give you a wool
package."
"Let's get
this straight," said the Sheep. "We give you our wool to use for
the common good, you give it to the Fat Cats, and when we get cold, we
have to go to work for the Fat Cats to get some of it back."
"Yep, that's
right," said the Sheepdog.
"Just checking,"
said the Sheep.
So, the Sheep
went to the Fat Cats and applied for jobs. Some were hired, and some
weren't. The ones who were hired indeed received excellent wool packages.
Of course, they had to work their mutton chops off, but at least they were
well provided for.
"Hey," said
the Sheep to the Sheepdog, "guess you were right. Sort of.
Some of us are doing pretty well working for the Fat Cats, but others have
kind of been left out in the cold."
"And what
fine, upstanding citizens you Working Sheep are!" said the Sheepdog.
"Not like those lazy, good for nothing Welfare Sheep."
The Working
Sheep decided that the Sheepdog was right. "We work our rumps off
for our wool benefits. We're a lot better than those other Sheep!"
"And those
of you who work for the Obscenely Obese Cats are the best of all!" said
the Sheepdog. "You get more wool than all the others!"
"That's true,"
said the Sheep who worked for the Obscenely Obese Cats. "We are better!"
The Working
Sheep labored on for some time, while the Welfare Sheep shivered and starved.
Sometimes they changed places. Then, one day, the Fat Cats called
the Working Sheep into a meeting.
"We're moving
our operations to South America," said the Fat Cats. "You're all
fired."
"What?" bleated
the Working Sheep. "But we're the backbone of your companies!"
"Yeah, yeah,"
said the Fat Cats, "but you're too expensive. We found some really
cheap Alpacas."
So, the ex-Working
Sheep went to the Sheepdog.
"Hey," they
complained, "your Fat Cats that were supposed to take care of us have split
for South America. So, at least, you can give us back some of our
wool, since they aren't stimulating the local economy."
"No way!"
barked the indignant Sheepdog. "We still have a social contract!
You have to give me your wool, and I don't have to give any back!
Besides, if you don't pay up, I'll introduce you to my Doberman and Rottweiler
buds. Anyway, I still have to pay off the Fat Cats. We're paying
for their factory in South America."
"Wha-a-at?"
baaed the Sheep. "Why are you, we mean 'we,' doing that? We
thought the rationale was that you gave them wool, and they brought business
in. Well, now they're taking business out."
"No no no
no no," insisted the Sheepdog. "You have to look at things from a
global perspective. The Fat Cats are stimulating the global economy.
That's good for everybody!"
"It doesn't
seem to be doing us any good," the Out-of-Work Sheep pointed out.
"It's all
your fault!" countered the Sheepdog.
"Our fault?"
bleated the Sheep. "How can it be our fault?"
"You aren't
buying enough," scolded the Sheepdog. "How can the Fat Cats do their
good deeds when you aren't buying their goods? Buy those Alpaca sweaters!"