In the Same Boat
copyright © 2003 by Robert L. Blau
Six travelers were sailing together in a small boat. A
large wave crashed over the side of the boat, partially filling it with water.
"We are in mortal peril!" cried the first passenger and
smashed a hole in the bottom of the boat forthwith. "There," he said
with satisfaction. "Now the water can get out the bottom, and the boat will
not sink. I have saved us all. Thank me, thank me."
"Now, just one cotton-pickin' minute!" objected the second
traveler. "Poking that hole was a good idea. Any rational person would
have done the same thing. But you were wrong not to consult with us
first."
"You're both wrong," declared the third traveler. "Sure,
the hole is a good idea, but it isn't big enough to let out all that
water. In fact, there seems to be more now than there was before. So
we need to make it bigger."
"I don't know about that," said the fourth traveler. "I
think the hole was a bad idea. Of course, now that it's there, we have
to live with it."
"You're all off base," said the fifth traveler. "The hole
is basically a good idea, but it needs tweaking. We need to get the
best tools for making holes and smoothing the edges to make it more efficient.
Perhaps we should open a second hole. We need a committee to
examine the options."
"Dang!" cried the sixth. "If we don't plug that damn thing
and start bailing right now, we're going to drown!"
"No no no!" cried the others. "That's radical and unrealistic.
The boat won't float without the hole."
They were in agreement for a very short time.