copyright © 2017
by Robert L. Blau
Once upon a time, a bunch of people decided to live together,
rather than individually. It seemed like a good idea because not
everyone was a good hunter, and not everyone was a good farmer, and not
everyone was a good weaver, and not everyone was a good fry cook, and
not everyone was a good plumber. And sex was darned inconvenient.
So they tried the living together experiment, but problems arose
immediately. The people discovered that, while they could live
together, they couldn't get along with each other. Fighting and
bickering were endemic. They fought over everything: land, food,
water, partners, business transactions. You name it. They
even fought over who named it. And what. The grand
experiment just wasn't working out.
Finally, someone had a bright idea. "What if," suggested this
person, "we tried to be nice to each other once in a while?"
Everyone decided that this was worth a try. (Well, almost
everyone. There's always one, you know?) So they tried the
nice thing out and found that it worked a lot better.
But there was just this one thing. "Being nice to one another is
too nebulous," said the Bright Ones, for there are always a few Bright
Ones in any group. "People are going to get
confused. If anyone asks us what, exactly,
is the basis of our society, a lot of us won't be able to answer
coherently, and then the whole thing will come apart. We have to
be able to state our fundamental principles coherently." At
length. this is what they came up with: "Do unto others as you
would have others do unto you." And the Bright Ones saw that it
was good.
But there was just this one thing. "We have a great credo," said
the Bright Ones, "but it can't be official until it is written down.
We can preach, 'Do unto others' and so forth, but anyone can
reply, 'Oh, yeah? Says who? Show me where it says that!'" So the credo was
duly written down, signed, approved, and enshrined. The written
credo became known as the Paper, and its adherents became known as the
People of the Paper. And the Bright Ones
saw that it was good.
But there was just this one thing. "It's not specific enough,"
said the Bright Ones. "Who are 'others,' for instance? Surely, we
shouldn't treat everyone the
same? What about Bad People? What about Them? What
about people who just aren't the right sort?" So the Paper was
amended, and soon grew from one short sentence to 786 pages. And
the Bright Ones saw that it was good.
But there was just this one thing. "It's
too complicated," said the Bright Ones. "Nobody can understand
it. We need a lot of smart people, one might say 'Bright Ones',
to interpret it." And so a great structure of Interpeters of the
Paper was established. And the Bright Ones saw that it was good.
But there was just this one thing. One day
the People of the Paper elected a new leader, and the new leader said,
"This is just a piece of paper." And he was right! So he
shoved the Paper through a shredder and sent the shreds to the
landfill, and no one was exactly clear on what had happened. So
they started fighting and bickering again.
The end.