The Intentions of the Founding Fathers
copyright © 2005 by Robert L. Blau

The Founding Fathers are meeting in Philadelphia ...

Jefferson:  James, I have a bone to pick with you.  I think we all do, in fact.

Madison:  Oh, yes?  What seems to be the problem, Tom?

Jefferson:  It's this document of yours, this so-called "Constitution."  We don't like it.

Madison:  What, specifically, is it that you don't like?  It isn't the preamble, is it?  I could change that.  It's just a lot of puffery, anyway.

Franklin:  No, James, that isn't the problem.  It's the whole document, you see.  We all agreed on what we wanted way back at the beginning of the Revolution.  Remember?

Madison:  A military theocracy serving the moneyed interests.  Of course.  So?

Washington:  Well, the Constitution should state right up front that the United States of America is a Christian nation.  Ten Commandments posted in every schoolhouse.  Where's that verbiage?

Madison:  Ah, I see.  I thought you all understood this.  I'm afraid it's a little too early to try to sell that.  The memory of King George stuffing the Church of England down everybody's throat is still a bit raw.

Washington:  Hmm.  Maybe.  But what's all this "separation of powers" crap?  You know that, if we intend to rule the world, we have to concentrate power in the hands of the executive.  (Ahem.)  See, I like the "Commander-in-Chief" bit, but what's all that nonsense about Congress having sole power to declare war?  If you leave it up to them, they'll just dawdle and dilly-dally, and we'll never get to invade anyone.

Madison:  Well, once again, we would have a very hard sell there.  The People just got through spilling their blood to kick out King George the tyrant.  They aren't going to be too happy about fighting on behalf of someone they would very likely perceive as a new tyrant.  And there is the name issue ...

Washington:  Ahem.  Yes, that is unfortunate.  I so wanted to be King, but "King George" just wouldn't go over too well at the moment.

John Adams:  What I particularly loathe is this notion of an independent judiciary.  You know, if you tell the judges that they're independent, pretty soon, they're going to start taking you seriously.  We can't have that!

Madison (nervously):  Uh, there is something I haven't told you yet.

The others glare expectantly at him.

Madison:  The People are demanding a Bill of Rights.  Freedom of speech, religion, assembly.  That sort of thing.  I thought we could skate by without that, but apparently, I was wrong.

All:  What?!

Jefferson:  Do you mean to say, that they can call us names, and we can't toss them in prison?  That's outrageous!  And I want to be able to tell people, "I am the government!"

Madison:  Patience, Tom.  I'm just bringing this up to show what we're up against.

Monroe:  But what are we to do?  If we put this Constitution thing out there - with a Bill of Rights, no less - people are going to think it represents the way we think government should be!

Madison:  I'm sorry, guys, but we have to be patient.  Remember, the Constitution is just a piece of paper.  In around 200 years, our true heirs will figure out what our intentions really were.